Monday, July 22, 2013

Justice for Whom?

Trayvon Martin was a child shot during an altercation with a neighborhood watch man. Controversy surrounded the case, as the child was African American. The prosecutor and defense attorney for George Zimmerman made cases. The verdict was not guilty. For many students this will cause elevated tension where race is involved because the role race played in this case and the media attention. This could cause tension in the classroom. I believe it can be nipped in the bud.

On a rainy February night, Trayvon Martin was walking through his neighborhood on his way home from the corner store. George Zimmerman, an armed neighborhood watch man, saw Martin walking and followed him. Zimmerman called the police to report he saw someone suspicious in the neighborhood. The dispatcher instructed Zimmerman not to follow Martin. Zimmerman continued to follow which led to an altercation that left an unarmed boy dead. This tragedy made George Zimmerman the focus of those looking at civil rights and gun laws. Florida state law allows you to use any force necessary to defend yourself when you feel like your life is in danger. My opinion is no force would have been necessary had he followed the advice of the dispatcher and stayed in his car. There has been a comparison to the senseless killing of Emmett Till. Emmett was a 14-year-old boy who was tortured, disfigured and murdered for supposedly flirting with a white girl in 1955 in Mississippi. There is no doubt anger and outrage will follow this case straight into history. The not guilty verdict has reinforced in the minds of African Americans across the country that the justice system has no regard or justice for them.

In the classroom, there should be an open discussion about diversity and racial profiling. Teachers must choose to discuss this case openly for the benefit of the students. It will be the topic on kids’ minds everywhere.  The tension among the students could be elevated. I believe there needs to be a safe venue for the students to express their feelings about the case. Journaling would be a great way to allow the students to vent without making them the target of children with differing opinions. There was clear profiling on both sides in this case. Martin assumed Zimmerman was up to no good because Zimmerman was following him that had Martin defensive. Zimmerman assumed Martin was up to no good because Martin was wearing a hooded sweatshirt and walking through the predominately-white neighborhood at night. There would be no case without the bias in the minds of these two people. In addition to talking in the classroom about diversity and profiling, there should be a discussion about the individual’s role in this case. The teacher can help manage her classrooms behavior and attitudes by being proactive rather than reactive. The teacher can establish positive teacher student relationships by truly understanding and relating to the attitudes and feelings of the students and their differing opinions. A classroom is a community, a family and should be treated as such. This will help our students feel like they belong and are safe in the learning environment.

 This case has made history. Sadly, most people will forget this ever happened within a few years. Most likely, African Americans will never forget this event. It was tragic and senseless taking of a young man’s life. In America, we have a right to bear arms. On the other hand, we do not have the right to use weapons to harass and kill someone walking through the neighborhood because we have a biased opinion of them. In addition, we do not have the right to assume the intentions of others based on our opinion of their skin tone and what we have been programmed to think about it. In conclusion, I feel Americans have not advanced our thinking where diversity is involved. We as educators must ensure that our students feel safe in our classrooms and the best way to ensure that is by being firm, fair and consistent always ensuring we are empathetic and understanding of our students feelings and opinions. The same way we would in our home environment.

References

ALCINDOR, Y. of USA TODAY (2013) DesMoines Register. Retrieved July 13, 2013 , from http://www.desmoinesregister.com/viewart/20130714/NEWS/307140066/Jury-Zimmerman-not-guilty-teen-s-death